Judge McKible is a host and a judge for the Beverly Hills Dog Show. For the 25th Annual Beverly Hills Dog Show, McKible is one of the judges who evaluates the dogs participating in terms of the three different categories; beauty, style, and talent. The contestants who are competing for the win of $50,000 are the Cortez family and their dogs, Delgado, Papi, Chloe, and Pedro, and Colleen Mansfield and her dog, Appoline. In the first round, Delgado was disqualified for his size, Pedro was applaud in the second round but when he "smiled" he was instantly dismissed, and in the third round, he dismissed Chloe for missing only one note while playing the piano. In the finals taking between Papi and Appoline, Colleen makes him question about his breeding papers and since since its against the rules to participate without them, Papi is disqualified thus making Colleen and Appoline winners by default.
Judge McKible's strict and sophisticated attitude has made earned him a dislike, not from the audience, but by the other judges as well for disqualifying some of the dogs unfairly.
McKible became one of the victims of the Anti-Hunters.
The Cortez Family
Colleen Mansfield and Appoline
Polly Wickham and Sterling Reed